Advertising sticker shock

Why focusing on the upfront cost of marketing can quietly sabotage your long-term growth.

As a business owner, you’ve likely felt that moment of sticker shock: chatting with a marketer, excited about promotion and growth, and then… boom—the price pops up. The mood shifts, ideas fade, and all of a sudden it’s easier to say, “Maybe later.”

Here’s the thing: marketing isn’t free—and that’s okay. What’s not okay is judging it purely by the price tag. Because when you do that, you’re missing what you’re really investing in.

What you’re really paying for

Marketing isn’t simply “design a graphic, post it, hope for leads.” It’s the time it takes to understand your business, your audience, where you sit in the market, and what your next move looks like.
It’s the expertise of someone who’s seen lots of different campaigns, knows what works (and what doesn’t), and can guide you through the clutter.
It’s someone helping you stay focused—so you don’t spray every message everywhere and hope something sticks.

Why cheap can be risky

When you pick the lowest cost option, you might end up with something that checks the boxes but doesn’t move the needle. You might get “a website,” but not one built to convert. “Graphics” might mean stock visuals thrown together. “Marketing” might mean a few posts that don’t connect.

The truth is: if marketing were easy, we’d all be doing it brilliantly on our own. Many business owners wear too many hats already—operations, customers, payroll, products. It’s easy for marketing to become “one more thing” you’re juggling, and as a result, it gets pushed to the back burner or handled on the cheap.

The smarter way: think investment, not expense

Here’s a practical view: a reasonable rule of thumb is to set aside about 7-10% of your annual revenue for marketing. It might feel like a lot, but if you approach it as an investment in business growth—not just an expense—you’ll shift your mindset. Big Opposable Blog

Let’s walk through an example: Suppose you pay $3,500 for a direct-mail campaign. You target 1,000 people, you get an average response rate (4%), you convert a few of those responses into customers, and suddenly you’re looking at $40,000 in revenue from that spend. The key isn’t the cost—it’s the return. Big Opposable Blog

How much should you spend on your marketing?



Choose the right partner

When you work with a marketer or an agency, you’re getting more than their hours. You’re getting their network—designers, copywriters, web folks, analysts. You’re getting someone focused on your success so you can focus on running your business.

Yes, there are folks out there charging $20/hr who might be “cheap.” There’s probably a reason why the rate is so low. The question you should ask is: Will this person advance my business, or simply fill a task?

In short: value > cost

Putting money into your marketing doesn’t guarantee success—but ignoring marketing when you’re already invisible? That’s almost a guarantee of missed opportunity.

So don’t treat marketing like a bill you dread. Treat it like the fuel for your next step. When you do, your mindset shifts—and so does your business.

Matt Schroeder

Chief Creative Monkey Matt Schroeder is a self-described “full-stack marketer, educator, brand builder, strategist, change agent, and teller of dad jokes.” With nearly 30 years of experience, Matt brings warm charm and personal touch to his marketing accounts. Beyond delivering sage marketing guidance and interesting visual graphics, it’s his goal to build genuine relationships with his customers and create an open, honest forum to exchange ideas, explore opportunities, and candidly evaluate the progress of marketing campaigns.

Matt boasts degrees in Graphic Design (A.A.S.), Web Development (B.S.), owns a Master’s degree in Marketing & Public Relations from University of Denver, and a professional certificate in Digital Marketing from the Kellogg School of Business at Northwestern University.

https://bigopposablethumb.com
Previous
Previous

The ultimate logo manifesto

Next
Next

The cost of an identity crisis.